Market Update and New Listings: Spring 2025

The Nantucket real estate market showed strong performance in April, continuing a promising trend for the year. Compared to April of the previous year, the number of properties sold surged by 63%, dollar volume more than doubled with a 109% increase, the average sold price rose by 28%, and the median sold price grew by 15%. The sustained high demand has been matched with more new listings, properties returning to the market, and fewer homes being removed from the market. Despite these year-over-year changes, the inventory at the end of the month remained nearly the same.

Maury People Sotheby's International Realty continues to lead the market, setting the pace with more than twice the sales and dollar volume of our closest competitor. When we’re not busy closing deals, we’re focused on listing new homes, recently adding 15 new properties, including iconic estates, waterfront beach homes, land opportunities, and more. Below is just a small selection of these exciting new offerings.

37 Sankaty Head Road
Sconset

Commanding a presence high on the Sconset Bluff, this private family compound is inarguably one of the most stunning properties on Nantucket. Sited...


8
BEDROOMS
8
BATHROOMS
$26,850,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

32A West Chester Street
Town

Charming and efficient, light and bright one bedroom year-round cottage with additional sleeping loft, built in 2007 set on an oversized and privat...


1
BEDROOMS
1
BATHROOMS
$2,500,000
USD

Jenny Paradis, Broker
508-325-3131 |

Roberta White, Broker
508-325-2019 |

16 Ahab Drive
Cisco

This beautifully maintained, single level living home features four bedrooms, two updated baths, in the quiet Hummock Pond Village location. A lar...


4
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$3,595,000
USD

Kathy Gallaher, Broker
508.560.0078 |

196 Cliff Road
Cliff

Ideally located on 1.84 acres near the Tupancy Links and Washing Pond, 196 Cliff Road is a timeless estate offering privacy, space, and an easy app...


5
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$7,999,995
USD

John McGarr, Sales Associate
508.577.5450 |

24 Flintlock Road
Tom Nevers

Nestled on an expansive 2.45-acre parcel adjoining pristine Nantucket Land Bank conservation land, 24 Flintlock Road offers a private and tranquil ...


10
BEDROOMS
9
BATHROOMS
$10,495,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

4 Fintry Lane
Dionis

WELCOME TO DIONIS seclusion ~ Set on 1.84 acres and enveloped by over 700 acres of pristine conservation land, this exceptional eight-bedroom estat...


8
BEDROOMS
7
BATHROOMS
$10,495,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

12 & 13 Shimmo Pond Road
Shimmo

Your Nantucket sanctuary awaits in one of the island's most desirable enclaves. Welcome to 12 Shimmo Pond Road, where you'll find a 4-Bedroom Main ...


6
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$5,495,000
USD

Sheila Carroll, Sales Associate
508.560.0488 |

Holly Finigan, Broker
978.201.2579 |

4 Crown Court
Town

Perched on highly sought after Academy Hill, one of Nantucket's most desirable and historic neighborhoods. 4 Crown Court is a gracious 5 bedroom, 6...


5
BEDROOMS
6
BATHROOMS
$5,995,000
USD

Daniel Barber, Broker
508.325.2072 |

17 Massachusetts Avenue
Madaket

A truly rare and prestigious opportunity to acquire direct waterfront property on Madaket Harbor. This exceptional offering includes a detached gar...


3
BEDROOMS
1
BATHROOMS
$11,500,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

5 Upper Tawpawshaw Road
Middle Moors

Welcome to "Edgemoor", a private island retreat nestled on a quiet cul de sac in Nantucket. This beautifully appointed 5 bedroom residence combine...


5
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$6,195,000
USD

Daniel Barber, Broker
508.325.2072 |

26 Easy Street, # B
Town

Prime Commercial/Residential Lot with Stunning Water Views. Located in a highly desirable location, this buildable lot offers an exceptional opport...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$2,850,000
USD

Lisa Winn, Broker
617.281.1500 |

Eliot Lees, Sales Associate
617-953-9530 |

26 Easy Street, # B
Town

Prime Commercial/Residential Lot with Stunning Water Views. Located in a highly desirable location, this buildable lot offers an exceptional opport...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$2,850,000
USD

Lisa Winn, Broker
617.281.1500 |

Eliot Lees, Sales Associate
617-953-9530 |

27 North Liberty Street
Town

A masterful 2024 restoration by renowned Kolb Architects has transformed this 1790 gem into a sophisticated in-town retreat, blending historic char...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$4,995,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

18 & 20 Somerset Lane
Hummock Pond

Welcome to 18 & 20 Somerset Lane, an exceptional gambrel post and beam house nestled on a generous .92 acres, offering unparalleled privacy in the ...


3
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$3,350,000
USD

Susan Lazarus, Sales Associate
508.221.3500 |

6 Nonantum Avenue
Surfside

Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a Nantucket beachside retreat in Surfside—one of the island’s most sought-after locations! 6 Nonantum A...


3
BEDROOMS
3
BATHROOMS
$4,999,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

4 Mariner Way
Town

Enjoy harbor views from the expansive deck off the 2nd floor of 4 Mariner Way. Newly built four-bedroom main residence with a separate one-bedroom ...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$6,895,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

1 West Sankaty Road & 29 Main Street
Sconset

Located on the idyllic, tree-lined Main Street in Sconset, this timeless white clapboard residence blends historic charm with contemporary living. ...


5
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$7,995,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

21 North Pasture Lane
Polpis

Spacious two-story residence with four bedrooms suites, situated in North Pasture abutting vast tracts of conservation land with easy access to mil...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$6,995,000
USD

Mary Taaffe, Broker
508.325.1526 |

41 Quidnet Road
Quidnet

Tucked just moments from Quidnet Village and sheltered behind high hedges, this special property blends timeless Nantucket charm with thoughtful mo...


3
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$7,195,000
USD

John McGarr, Sales Associate
508.577.5450 |

27 Wigwam Road
Madequecham

Tucked near one of Nantucket’s most beloved South Shore beaches, this 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath upside-down beach house is a true coastal gem. Designed...


5
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$4,750,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

2A Forrest Avenue, # Unit 5
Mid Island

This unique property offers exceptional versatility and functionality, featuring an oversized three-bay garage is ideal for vehicle storage. Above ...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$2,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

2B Forrest Avenue, # Unit 6
Mid Island

This unique property offers exceptional versatility and functionality, featuring an oversized three-bay garage is ideal for vehicle storage. Above ...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$2,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

10 Silver Street
Town

Modern Elegance in the Heart of Town- 10 Silver Street presents a rare opportunity to own a newly constructed retreat in one of Nantucket’s most ...


8
BEDROOMS
8
BATHROOMS
$6,995,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

62 Nobadeer Avenue
Surfside

A rare opportunity to build your dream beach house on Nantucket’s highly sought-after south shore. This .69-acre parcel comes with approved archi...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$5,499,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

11 Columbus Avenue
Madaket

This home features four gorgeous bedrooms, four and one half baths and stunning unobstructed views of the Atlantic Ocean. Every detail was well tho...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$4,595,000
USD

Kathy Gallaher, Broker
508.560.0078 |

12 Willard Street
Brant Point

Welcome to 12 Willard Street, a stunning coastal retreat located in the heart of Brant Point, one of Nantucket’s most desirable neighborhoods. Th...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$6,495,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

9 Correia Lane
Surfside

Welcome to a rare opportunity to own an HDC approved family compound on a serene, quiet road just moments from the pristine shores of Surfside Beac...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$2,400,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

2B Forrest Avenue, # Unit 2
Mid Island

Experience the privacy of a free-standing condo combined with the ease of low-maintenance living. Built with high-quality stick construction and ac...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

2A Forrest Avenue, # Unit 1
Mid Island

Experience the privacy of a free-standing condo combined with the ease of low-maintenance living. Built with high-quality stick construction and ac...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

52 Monomoy Road
Monomoy

Commanding one of the most coveted harborfront locations on Nantucket, this extraordinary 1.25-acre estate offers truly unparalleled harborfront vi...


10
BEDROOMS
7
BATHROOMS
$34,500,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

69 Orange Street
Town

This beautifully restored and well-maintained federal-style home from the 1830s, located on historic Orange Street, offers a perfect blend of antiq...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$5,195,000
USD

John Trudel, Sales Associate
508.648.8870 |

Craig Hawkins, Broker
|

21 Quidnet Road
Quidnet

Located in one of the most desirable areas of Nantucket, this 3.78 acre estate has it all! Welcome to High Point where two impeccably designed hom...


9
BEDROOMS
7
BATHROOMS
$9,495,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

4 Sunset Hill Lane
Town

Four sunset hill is a home that breathes history tucked into the heart of Nantucket town and perched on a high point. This home tells the story of ...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$5,950,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

1 Ocean Avenue
Sconset

A legacy estate in the heart of ’Sconset, One Ocean Avenue is one of Nantucket’s most iconic offerings. Spanning three parcels and perched abov...


12
BEDROOMS
10
BATHROOMS
$22,750,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

Search Sales Listings

Subscribe to LINK

Nantucket’s multiple listing service.