Nantucket Real Estate: Quarter 1 2025

With the first quarter of 2025 behind us, the year is already shaping up to be another strong one for Nantucket real estate. Year-to-date dollar volume has risen by 24%, and transactions are up 43%, signaling a promising start, especially given that 2024 was the fourth-highest year on record for total dollar volume sold. These early trends suggest 2025 should be another robust year. 

Demand remains strong, while inventory levels are still low, similar to last year. With many buyers eager to secure homes before summer, now is an excellent time to list your property. At the end of the first quarter, Maury People Sotheby's International Realty has continued as the leader on Nantucket by selling nearly twice as many properties as its nearest competitor, including the top 2 highest sales: 14 Lincoln Avenue at $21M and 47 Hulbert Avenue at $15M.

Our office has recently listed the following properties, with more to come.

12 Shimmo Pond Road
Shimmo

Quintessential Nantucket Retreat: Enchanting 4-Bedroom Home with 2-Bedroom Cottage on expansive grounds in the prestigious Shimmo location. Shimmo ...


6
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$5,800,000
USD

Sheila Carroll, Sales Associate
508.560.0488 |

103 Main Street
Town

Cobble’s End sits at the crown of one of America’s most historic and picturesque streets—Main Street, Nantucket—where cobblestones meet bri...


6
BEDROOMS
7
BATHROOMS
$19,995,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

2B Yawkey Way
Mid Island

Spacious and well built duplex by local high-end contractor with 30 years experience building on the island. The left half has three floors of fin...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,595,000
USD

John Trudel, Sales Associate
508.648.8870 |

62 Nobadeer Avenue
Surfside

A rare opportunity to build your dream beach house on Nantucket’s highly sought-after south shore. This .69-acre parcel comes with approved archi...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$5,995,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

11 Columbus Avenue
Madaket

This home features four gorgeous bedrooms, four and one half baths and stunning unobstructed views of the Atlantic Ocean. Every detail was well tho...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$4,595,000
USD

Kathy Gallaher, Broker
508.560.0078 |

12 Willard Street
Brant Point

Welcome to 12 Willard Street, a stunning coastal retreat located in the heart of Brant Point, one of Nantucket’s most desirable neighborhoods. Th...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$6,825,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

9 Correia Lane
Surfside

Welcome to a rare opportunity to own an HDC approved family compound on a serene, quiet road just moments from the pristine shores of Surfside Beac...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$2,400,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

2 Elbow Lane
Sconset

Welcome to “The Gift,” a one-of-a-kind Sconset antique cottage tucked into the heart of the village. Step back in time and enjoy the simple 'Sc...


2
BEDROOMS
1
BATHROOMS
$2,075,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

2B Forrest Avenue, # Unit 2
Mid Island

Experience the privacy of a free-standing condo combined with the ease of low-maintenance living. Built with high-quality stick construction and ac...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

2A Forrest Avenue, # Unit 1
Mid Island

Experience the privacy of a free-standing condo combined with the ease of low-maintenance living. Built with high-quality stick construction and ac...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

52 Monomoy Road
Monomoy

Commanding one of the most coveted harborfront locations on Nantucket, this extraordinary 1.25-acre estate offers truly unparalleled harborfront vi...


10
BEDROOMS
7
BATHROOMS
$34,500,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

11 Perry Lane
Miacomet

Private 3 bedroom home at the end of a private street. This property is located in highly sought after CTEC zoning, which allows for multiple mixe...


3
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,950,000
USD

John Trudel, Sales Associate
508.648.8870 |

69 Orange Street
Town

This beautifully restored and well-maintained federal-style home from the 1830s, located on historic Orange Street, offers a perfect blend of antiq...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$5,195,000
USD

John Trudel, Sales Associate
508.648.8870 |

Craig Hawkins, Broker
|

21 Quidnet Road
Quidnet

Located in one of the most desirable areas of Nantucket, this 3.78 acre estate has it all! Welcome to High Point where two impeccably designed hom...


9
BEDROOMS
7
BATHROOMS
$9,995,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

4 Sunset Hill Lane
Town

Four sunset hill is a home that breathes history tucked into the heart of Nantucket town and perched on a high point. This home tells the story of ...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$5,950,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

1 Ocean Avenue
Sconset

A legacy estate in the heart of ’Sconset, One Ocean Avenue is one of Nantucket’s most iconic offerings. Spanning three parcels and perched abov...


12
BEDROOMS
10
BATHROOMS
$22,750,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

84 Cliff Road
Cliff

OPPORTUNITY to own a home in the sought after Cliff area in this newly constructed 5 bedroom and 5.5 bath main house with attached garage, 1 bedroo...


6
BEDROOMS
6
BATHROOMS
$7,995,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

6 Mariner Way
Town

6 Mariner Way stands as one of the island’s only HARBOR VIEW, new construction, turn-key properties with immediate access to both Town and the ha...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$7,225,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

2 Fawn Lane
Mid Island

Custom new construction conveniently located to Surfside beaches, Nantucket town, and bike paths this 4245 sq. ft. single family home was thoughtfu...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$3,275,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

181 Polpis Road
Polpis

Properties such as 181 Polpis Road, offering a timeless Nantucket setting, are becoming nearly impossible to find. Steeped in the Island's farming...


5
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$3,195,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

20 North Pasture Lane
Polpis

Welcome to 20 North Pasture Lane, a stunningly reimagined estate nestled in the serene Polpis area of Nantucket. Set on 2.75 acres bordering conser...


5
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$11,995,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

41 Old South Road
Mid Island

Turn-key two-bedroom, two-bath apartment with a private one-car garage and spacious lockable storage area in the basement. Unit G, a 2-bedroom con...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,195,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

7 North Swift Rock Road
Dionis

A truly peaceful location and rare offering in one of the island's coveted and exclusive locations, this custom built, three bedroom, three full ba...


3
BEDROOMS
3
BATHROOMS
$10,800,000
USD

Kathy Gallaher, Broker
508.560.0078 |

16 Milestone Road
Monomoy

Nestled in the highly sought-after Monomoy neighborhood, this inviting home offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and coastal charm- ideal as...


3
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,995,000
USD

Donna Barnett, Broker
508.221.8995 |

Sheila Carroll, Sales Associate
508.560.0488 |

6 Fawn Lane
Mid Island

The Preserve at Fawn Lane is a 10-home development less than two miles to town with easy access to all of Nantucket's beaches. This home features 3...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$4,000,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

8 Grey Lady Lane
Miacomet

Welcome to the epitome of modern living at Grey Lady Lane! This meticulously crafted 5 bedroom, 5 bath new construction home boasts three floors of...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$3,649,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

6 Marion Avenue
Cisco

Discover coastal elegance in this timeless 4-bedroom, 3 full and 2 half-bath home featuring 4 fireplaces and sweeping southwest ocean views. Situat...


4
BEDROOMS
3
BATHROOMS
$7,495,000
USD

Ryan Blaney, Sales Associate
781.910.6470 |

8 Chuck Hollow Road
Tom Nevers

Sitting in the serene environment of Tom Nevers East, "Wildflowers" boasts a perfect blend of comfort and luxury. Newly renovated in 2024, each of ...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$7,700,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

2 Mariner Way
Town

2 Mariner Way stands as one of the island’s only new construction, turn-key properties with immediate access to both Town and the harbor. Perfect...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$6,995,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

20 Bishops Rise
Dionis

Tucked away in one of the island’s most exclusive neighborhoods, this newly constructed coastal compound offers a rare blend of refined luxury an...


9
BEDROOMS
8
BATHROOMS
$12,325,000
USD

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

17 Cannonbury Lane
Sconset

17 Cannonbury Lane captures the spirit of a quintessential Nantucket summer—just moments from the beach and a short bike ride to the charm of ’...


7
BEDROOMS
7
BATHROOMS
$7,995,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

137 Surfside Road
Surfside

If your ideal island summer includes the sound of the surf, starlit nights, easy access to Nantucket's favorite ocean beach, and a bike path leadin...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$2,895,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

14 Correia Lane
Surfside

Luxury Estate in Surfside - Your Dream Home Awaits! Introducing a brand new. exquisite construction in the heart of Surfside! This magnificent prop...


6
BEDROOMS
6
BATHROOMS
$13,995,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

15 Fawn Lane
Mid Island

Welcome to the Preserve at Fawn Lane. 15 Fawn Lane is a brand new, beautiful, spacious home with 5+ bedrooms, 5 full baths and 2 half baths. Br...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$3,795,000
USD

Lisa Winn, Broker
617.281.1500 |

Eliot Lees, Sales Associate
617-953-9530 |

17 New Street
Sconset

Sconset Gem ~ Two cottages on a spacious lot in the heart of 'Sconset, along with an additional doll house, a quaint summer compound ready for your...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$3,795,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

36 Warrens Landing Road
Eel Point

Nestled on Nantucket's prestigious Eel Point area, 36 Warrens Landing Road is an extraordinary estate finished in 2017, offering unparalleled luxur...


7
BEDROOMS
8
BATHROOMS
$21,000,000
USD

John McGarr, Sales Associate
508.577.5450 |

15 Meader Street
Town

Your island escape awaits!! Sophisticated turnkey 2 bedroom cottage located in the heart of Nantucket's historic village, less than one block from ...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$2,895,000
USD

Jenny Paradis, Broker
508-325-3131 |

Roberta White, Broker
508-325-2019 |

15 Meader Street
Town

2 charming and sophisticated cottages (4 bedrooms total) side by side with harbor views that provide a wonderful opportunity for a variety of uses....


4
BEDROOMS
3
BATHROOMS
$4,995,000
USD

Jenny Paradis, Broker
508-325-3131 |

Roberta White, Broker
508-325-2019 |

12 Correia Lane
Surfside

Luxurious 6-Bedroom Home in Newly Developed Surfside Area with Exceptional Amenities. The main house welcomes you with a first-floor en suite bedro...


6
BEDROOMS
6
BATHROOMS
$10,995,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

13 Fawn Lane
Mid Island

Seize the unique opportunity to build your dream home on Nantucket Island. The Preserve at Fawn Lane the ideal place to live. Featuring 5 bedrooms...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$1,595,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

4 Fawn Lane
Mid Island

Seize the unique opportunity to build your dream home on Nantucket Island. The Preserve at Fawn Lane the ideal place to live. Featuring 5 bedrooms,...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$1,595,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

8 Cliff Road
Cliff

Prime Cliff Road Location! Experience the charm and history of the Captain McKay House in this stunning first-floor condominium. Step into a sunlit...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$2,149,000
USD

Sheila Carroll, Sales Associate
508.560.0488 |

18 Creek Lane
Fishers Landing

Beautifully designed and well built by one of Nantucket's premier builders, the home maximizes the stunning south by south west view that spans ove...


3
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$4,350,000
USD

Kathy Gallaher, Broker
508.560.0078 |

54 & 56 Meadow View Drive
Hummock Pond

This exquisite hidden gem, surrounded by breathtaking landscaping, offers a serene retreat for your Nantucket dream home. Ideally situated just 1.5...


5
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$6,995,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

16 Gladlands Avenue
Surfside

Experience the best of summer at this inviting retreat, set on nearly two private acres abutting Land Bank land in the desirable Surfside area. Des...


4
BEDROOMS
3
BATHROOMS
$4,495,000
USD

Susan Chambers, Broker
508.560.0671 |

32 Pine Street
Town

"Pine is Mine" is a beautifully renovated antique home in a prime in-town location, nestled on one of Nantucket’s most charming and quintessentia...


3
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$3,295,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

Search Sales Listings

Subscribe to LINK

Nantucket’s multiple listing service.