Nantucket Real Estate: Quarter 1 2025

With the first quarter of 2025 behind us, the year is already shaping up to be another strong one for Nantucket real estate. Year-to-date dollar volume has risen by 24%, and transactions are up 43%, signaling a promising start, especially given that 2024 was the fourth-highest year on record for total dollar volume sold. These early trends suggest 2025 should be another robust year. 

Demand remains strong, while inventory levels are still low, similar to last year. With many buyers eager to secure homes before summer, now is an excellent time to list your property. At the end of the first quarter, Maury People Sotheby's International Realty has continued as the leader on Nantucket by selling nearly twice as many properties as its nearest competitor, including the top 2 highest sales: 14 Lincoln Avenue at $21M and 47 Hulbert Avenue at $15M.

Our office has recently listed the following properties, with more to come.

24 Flintlock Road
Tom Nevers

Nestled on an expansive 2.45-acre parcel adjoining pristine Nantucket Land Bank conservation land, 24 Flintlock Road offers a private and tranquil ...


10
BEDROOMS
9
BATHROOMS
$10,495,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

12 & 13 Shimmo Pond Road
Shimmo

Your Nantucket sanctuary awaits in one of the island's most desirable enclaves. Welcome to 12 Shimmo Pond Road, where you'll find a 4-Bedroom Main ...


6
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$5,495,000
USD

Sheila Carroll, Sales Associate
508.560.0488 |

Holly Finigan, Broker
978.201.2579 |

5 Upper Tawpawshaw Road
Middle Moors

Welcome to "Edgemoor", a private island retreat nestled on a quiet cul de sac in Nantucket. This beautifully appointed 5 bedroom residence combine...


5
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$6,195,000
USD

Daniel Barber, Broker
508.325.2072 |

26 Easy Street, # B
Town

Prime Commercial/Residential Lot with Stunning Water Views. Located in a highly desirable location, this buildable lot offers an exceptional opport...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$2,850,000
USD

Lisa Winn, Broker
617.281.1500 |

Eliot Lees, Sales Associate
617-953-9530 |

26 Easy Street, # B
Town

Prime Commercial/Residential Lot with Stunning Water Views. Located in a highly desirable location, this buildable lot offers an exceptional opport...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$2,850,000
USD

Lisa Winn, Broker
617.281.1500 |

Eliot Lees, Sales Associate
617-953-9530 |

2B Forrest Avenue, # Unit 6
Mid Island

This unique property offers exceptional versatility and functionality, featuring an oversized three-bay garage is ideal for vehicle storage. Above ...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$2,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

2A Forrest Avenue, # Unit 5
Mid Island

This unique property offers exceptional versatility and functionality, featuring an oversized three-bay garage is ideal for vehicle storage. Above ...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$2,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

27 Wigwam Road
Madequecham

Tucked near one of Nantucket’s most beloved South Shore beaches, this 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath upside-down beach house is a true coastal gem. Designed...


5
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$4,750,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

10 Silver Street
Town

Modern Elegance in the Heart of Town- 10 Silver Street presents a rare opportunity to own a newly constructed retreat in one of Nantucket’s most ...


8
BEDROOMS
8
BATHROOMS
$6,995,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

11 Columbus Avenue
Madaket

This home features four gorgeous bedrooms, four and one half baths and stunning unobstructed views of the Atlantic Ocean. Every detail was well tho...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$4,595,000
USD

Kathy Gallaher, Broker
508.560.0078 |

12 Willard Street
Brant Point

Welcome to 12 Willard Street, a stunning coastal retreat located in the heart of Brant Point, one of Nantucket’s most desirable neighborhoods. Th...


4
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$6,495,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

9 Correia Lane
Surfside

Welcome to a rare opportunity to own an HDC approved family compound on a serene, quiet road just moments from the pristine shores of Surfside Beac...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$2,400,000
USD

Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate
508.325.2897 |

Jessica Newman, Sales Associate
978.979.0588 |

2B Forrest Avenue, # Unit 2
Mid Island

Experience the privacy of a free-standing condo combined with the ease of low-maintenance living. Built with high-quality stick construction and ac...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

2A Forrest Avenue, # Unit 1
Mid Island

Experience the privacy of a free-standing condo combined with the ease of low-maintenance living. Built with high-quality stick construction and ac...


2
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$1,395,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

21 Quidnet Road
Quidnet

Located in one of the most desirable areas of Nantucket, this 3.78 acre estate has it all! Welcome to High Point where two impeccably designed hom...


9
BEDROOMS
7
BATHROOMS
$9,495,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

Search Sales Listings