The end of September marked the close of another quarter that outpaced last year’s performance. Continued high demand fueled nearly a 40% increase in the number of sold properties in Q3, even as inventory levels declined.
As the island quiets down for the shoulder and off-season, it remains an excellent time for homeowners to consider listing their properties. Selling in the off-season offers several distinct advantages:
Reduced Competition: With fewer listings, your home has a better chance to stand out.
Easier Showings: Properties are more accessible, making it simpler for potential buyers to schedule viewings.
Motivated Buyers: Many buyers are eager to secure a home for Summer 2026 and are ready to act quickly.
Strong Demand: Buyer interest remains high, and while the market is robust, there’s no guarantee it will stay this way—now is the prime time to list.
If you’re considering selling, reach out to one of our dedicated agents today. Year after year, we lead the island in listings and sales. Our deep knowledge of the Nantucket market, combined with the global reach of Sotheby’s International Realty, ensures your home receives the attention it deserves. Let us help you make the most of this opportunity.
Sell With Us
New Listings
Town
Just moments from the core of downtown Nantucket, "Watercolors" delivers what so many in-town buyers want but so few properties can offer: the time...
Bernadette Meyer, Broker 508.680.4748 |
Surfside
Positioned in the heart of Surfside, one of Nantucket’s most desirable south shore settings, this 20,000 SF lot (sub-division in progress) offers...
Bernadette Meyer, Broker 508.680.4748 |
Surfside
A rare offering in one of Surfside’s most coveted locations, this newly created 30,000 SF lot (in progress) provides the foundation for a true Na...
Bernadette Meyer, Broker 508.680.4748 |
Madequecham
Completely reimagined, this modern oceanfront retreat blends state-of-the-art design with uncompromising quality. Positioned on the south shore, th...
Bernadette Meyer, Broker 508.680.4748 |
Sandpiper
Sandpiper Place Opportunity! Rare oversized 16,000+ SF lot with HDC-approved modular plans—start building now or design your own. Generous ground...
Bernadette Meyer, Broker 508.680.4748 |
Town
Very unique property located West of Town in a Cliff location this property boasts two homes on one parcel with a swimming pool and hot tub. Elevat...
Chandra Miller, Broker 508.360.7777 |
Town
Less than a mile from town with a pool, hot tub and cabana, this newer construction five-bedroom home offers the complete Nantucket lifestyle. The ...
Bernadette Meyer, Broker 508.680.4748 |
Town
13 Orange Street is a rare in-town opportunity that blends historic character with modern comfort. Meticulously maintained with historic details pr...
Bernadette Meyer, Broker 508.680.4748 |
Tom Nevers
1, 3 & 3A Reeds Way. Elevated Oceanfront Expanding Over Nearly 6 Acres.
A once in a lifetime opportunity to own this rare Tom Nevers offering brin...
Gary Winn, Principal Broker 508.330.3069 |
Morgan Winn, Sales Associate 508.332.9088 |
Kathy Gallaher, Broker 508.560.0078 |
Tom Nevers
Oceanfront Retreat | 3 & 3A Reeds Way
Positioned along Nantucket’s striking south shore, offering privately owned deeded beach access, this rare ...
Gary Winn, Principal Broker 508.330.3069 |
Morgan Winn, Sales Associate 508.332.9088 |
Kathy Gallaher, Broker 508.560.0078 |
Tom Nevers
A once in a life time opportunity to own this extraordinary six-bedroom, five-bathroom residence on nearly three acres of premier oceanfront, risin...
Gary Winn, Principal Broker 508.330.3069 |
Morgan Winn, Sales Associate 508.332.9088 |
Kathy Gallaher, Broker 508.560.0078 |
Mid Island
Turnkey and light-filled three bedroom/2.5 bath townhouse centrally located ideal for year-round or summer living. Enjoy ease of living in a wonder...
Jenny Paradis, Broker 508-325-3131 |
Roberta White, Broker 508-325-2019 |
Fishers Landing
Set at the end of a quiet lane in Fisher’s Landing, this property is a complete package offering privacy, convenience, and versatility. Overlooki...
Bernadette Meyer, Broker 508.680.4748 |
Hummock Pond
A rare offering in Cisco, this eight-bedroom estate presents an extraordinary opportunity to own a luxury property with strong rental history in on...
Marybeth Gibson, Sales Associate 508.325.2897 |
Hummock Pond
Nestled in the desirable Hussey Farm neighborhood, this total reconstruction offers the perfect balance of modern luxury and classic Nantucket char...
Gary Winn, Principal Broker 508.330.3069 |
Morgan Winn, Sales Associate 508.332.9088 |
Town
Incredible opportunity on West Chester Street!! Two oversized lots (total of 12,632 sf in the Residential Old Historical district) with an existing...
Jenny Paradis, Broker 508-325-3131 |
Roberta White, Broker 508-325-2019 |
Monomoy
Tucked away in one of the island’s most peaceful enclaves, this expansive parcel at 4 Cathcart Road presents a rare chance to craft a private com...
Morgan Winn, Sales Associate 508.332.9088 |
Town
An exceptional in-town opportunity, this home combines space, style, and convenience in a way rarely found downtown. The three-level main house is ...
Bernadette Meyer, Broker 508.680.4748 |
Sconset
Commanding a presence high on the Sconset Bluff, this private family compound is inarguably one of the most stunning properties on Nantucket. Sited...
Gary Winn, Principal Broker 508.330.3069 |
Morgan Winn, Sales Associate 508.332.9088 |
Town
Charming and efficient, light and bright one bedroom year-round cottage with additional sleeping loft, built in 2007 set on an oversized and privat...
Jenny Paradis, Broker 508-325-3131 |
Roberta White, Broker 508-325-2019 |
Cisco
This beautifully maintained, single level living home features four bedrooms, two updated baths, in the quiet Hummock Pond Village location. A lar...
Kathy Gallaher, Broker 508.560.0078 |
Tom Nevers
Nestled on an expansive 2.45-acre parcel adjoining pristine Nantucket Land Bank conservation land, 24 Flintlock Road offers a private and tranquil ...
Chandra Miller, Broker 508.360.7777 |
