The Nantucket Real Estate Market: Rounding out 2025

Happy holidays! Nantucket real estate stayed strong in 2025, and it’s on track to finish as the third-best year on record by total sales volume (with an outside chance of sneaking into second if December closes exceptionally strong). Buyers had a little more room to be selective and negotiate when pricing didn’t match the market, but homes priced in line with the market moved quickly. For sellers, demand was there; results came down to smart pricing, solid prep, and great presentation. Whether you were watching the high end or the core market, 2025 proved that Nantucket continues to be a place where quality and scarcity matter.

That’s where Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty leads. We combine deep local knowledge with the global reach of Sotheby’s International Realty to connect Nantucket listings with serious buyers, market them beautifully, and negotiate hard for our clients. Heading into 2026, Nantucket remains Nantucket: well-priced, well-presented properties will always get attention—and the right guidance can make all the difference. If you’re curious what your home could achieve in today’s market, or you’re thinking about a move in the new year, we’re here to help.

New Listings

21 Kittiwake Lane
Naushop

This exceptional Naushop residence offers an ideal blend of comfort and convenience. The home features a main-level primary suite with an updated b...


3
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$2,350,000
USD

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

12A Greglen Avenue
Mid Island

Opportunity to own a piece of commercial land on Nantucket in the CTEC zoning district offering 40% ground cover allowable supporting a variety of ...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$1,795,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

44 Madequecham Valley Road
Madequecham

Step back in time to one of Nantucket’s last remaining 1940s waterfront beach houses. Set on an oversized parcel in 3-acre zoning, 44 Madequecham...


3
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$4,995,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

9 Nobadeer Way
Mid Island

Fantastic Multi-Unit Investment Opportunity — HDC and Planning Board Approved Plans for up to 14 Bedrooms. Quiet cul-de-sac location with town w...


3
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
$2,250,000
USD

Mark Norris, Sales Associate
508.566.2013 |

121 Surfside Road
Surfside

121 Surfside Road, Nantucket is a rare compound opportunity less than a mile from Surfside Beach and The Surf snack shack. Set on nearly a full acr...


4
BEDROOMS
6
BATHROOMS
$4,850,000
USD

Gary Winn, Principal Broker
508.330.3069 |

Morgan Winn, Sales Associate
508.332.9088 |

15 Skyline Drive
Surfside

Just minutes from the South Shore beaches yet worlds away, this spectacular Surfside estate offers over 3 acres of unparalleled privacy surrounded ...


5
BEDROOMS
4
BATHROOMS
$4,495,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

25 Nobadeer Avenue Lot 2
Surfside

Positioned in the heart of Surfside, one of Nantucket’s most desirable south shore settings, this 20,000 SF lot offers exceptional potential for ...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$3,500,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

6 Honeysuckle Drive
Sandpiper

Sandpiper Place Opportunity! Rare oversized 16,000+ SF lot with HDC-approved modular plans—start building now or design your own. Generous ground...


0
BEDROOMS
0
BATHROOMS
$1,350,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

15 Gingy Lane
Town

Very unique property located West of Town in a Cliff location this property boasts two homes on one parcel with a swimming pool and hot tub. Elevat...


10
BEDROOMS
9
BATHROOMS
$8,650,000
USD

Chandra Miller, Broker
508.360.7777 |

4 Red Mill Lane
Town

Less than a mile from town with a pool, hot tub and cabana, this newer construction five-bedroom home offers the complete Nantucket lifestyle. The ...


5
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$6,950,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

18 Mill Street
Town

An exceptional in-town opportunity, this home combines space, style, and convenience in a way rarely found downtown. The three-level main house is ...


6
BEDROOMS
5
BATHROOMS
$7,195,000
USD

Bernadette Meyer, Broker
508.680.4748 |

Search Sales Listings