1 Liberty Street, Nantucket MA

Steeped in three centuries of island history, this magnificent Nantucket antique offers a rare opportunity to live within the legacy of the historic downtown district. Originally built between 1720 and 1726 for Lydia Starbuck and Benjamin Barney, the home was masterfully preserved in a landmark 1969 renovation by the Nantucket Historic Trust. Every corner of this residence whispers stories of the past, from the exquisite original paneling to the beautiful fireplaces(decorative only)that anchor each room in warmth and character.

The main level is designed for both quiet reflection and grand entertaining. A study with half bath and a charming queen ensuite bedroom flank the entry, leading you towards the living room that flows seamlessly into the formal dining area. The kitchen provides access onto a private patio. Here, you can enjoy morning coffee or host summer dinner parties (gas grill). The second floor is a sanctuary of comfort, highlighted by a primary suite that underwent a 2020 renovation to include a glass shower and a spacious dressing area. Three additional twin bedrooms—including two twin ensuites  and one with a half bath ensure plenty of room for family and guests. With the rare convenience of garage parking for 1 car and the modern luxury of Central AC, this home perfectly balances its 18th-century soul with 21st-century ease.