Sheila Carroll

Sales Associate
Maury People Sotheby's International Realty
508-228-1881 x129
508.560.0488


With 30 years of experience in Nantucket real estate, Sheila brings deep market knowledge, unwavering dedication, and a personal connection to the island that sets her apart. Her exceptional attention to detail and warm, approachable style make her the perfect choice for buyers, sellers, and renters looking for a seamless and enjoyable real estate experience.

Sheilas journey in real estate began in 1994 as an administrator at Denby Real Estate, where she quickly discovered her passion for the industry. She obtained her Massachusetts real estate license in 1995 and joined Maury People Sotheby's International Realty, the island's premier and leading real estate firm. Over the decades, she has developed a keen ability to navigate complex transactions, ensuring her clients feel informed, confident, and well cared for. Whether representing sellers, buyers, or renters, Sheila's commitment to excellence and meticulous approach make all the difference.

Sheila first arrived on Nantucket in 1988 with college friends, spending the summer working as a nanny for a local family a family that remains an important part of her life today. She quickly fell in love with the Islands history, beauty, and small-town charm. What started as a summer adventure became a lifelong home, where she and her husband Kevin raised their two sons, Liam and Patrick, both proud Nantucket natives.

Beyond her professional success, Sheila is deeply connected to the Nantucket community. She finds joy in exploring the islands stunning landscapes whether taking quiet walks in Shimmo, the Moors, or along the beach with her rescue dogs, Bubba and Rolly. When she's not assisting clients, she enjoys yoga, reading, cooking, traveling the world, and spending quality time with family and friends. 

For Sheila, Nantucket is more than just a place it's a way of life. She understands that buying or selling a home here is about creating a lifetime of memories, friendships, and experiences. Whether you're new to the island or a longtime visitor, she is dedicated to helping you find your own special place on Nantucket.

With a strong work ethic, integrity, and a passion for connecting people with their dream homes, Sheila is honored to be a part of Maury People Sotheby's International Realty and looks forward to helping you make Nantucket your home.


Current Listings for Sheila Carroll

12 & 13 Shimmo Pond Road
Shimmo

SHIMMO: Charming 4-Bedroom Home with 2-Bedroom Cottage on expansive grounds in the coveted Shimmo locale. Shimmo Pond Road, where sandy paths wind beneath leafy canopies and Nantucket Harbor....


6
BEDROOMS
4/2
BATHROOMS
$5,800,000
USD

Recently Sold by Sheila Carroll

26-creek-lane-nantucket-ma
Fishers Landing

3
BEDROOMS
3/2
BATHROOMS
$2,200,000
Sold Price
74r-center-street-nantucket-ma
Town

1
BEDROOMS
1/2
BATHROOMS
$2,175,000
Sold Price
16a-milestone-road-nantucket-ma
Monomoy

3
BEDROOMS
2/2
BATHROOMS
$1,890,000
Sold Price
1-field-avenue-nantucket-ma
Surfside

4
BEDROOMS
2/2
BATHROOMS
$1,800,000
Sold Price
8a-cliff-road-nantucket-ma
Cliff

2
BEDROOMS
2/2
BATHROOMS
$1,799,000
Sold Price
19-cynthia-lane-nantucket-ma
Mid Island

5
BEDROOMS
3/2
BATHROOMS
$1,495,000
Sold Price